Project: Evaluation of CO2 sensors

some sensors still in calibration phase

In my home automation system I use CO2 sensors from Netatmo and some MH-Z14A based arduino nodes.

I really like, that the Netatmo sensors work for about a year on battery. But they can only be integrated with a cloud api into my home automation. This has led to one interruption of several hours in the past, when the service was down. As I regulate my heating with the measured data of these sensors, this was problematic. 🙂

What I am missing with the battery powered Netatmo sensors, is a led indicating air quality.

To remove the dependency of the cloud api, I decided to build my own sensors. But before I order more MH-Z14A sensors, I want to make an evaluation.

Caution: This article is about the experiences I made in my setup with the sensors I have and with the (maybe buggy) code I wrote. It may be, that you can not reproduce my findings. 🙂

goal:
evaluate CO2 sensors for Netatmo replacement

motivation:

  • I don’t want to be dependent on cloud
  • I wan’t a led indicating air quality with every sensor

deliverables:

  • prototype with every sensor
  • graphs of measurements made with different sensors
  • decision for one sensor

approach:

  • buy samples of different sensors
  • build a prototype with all sensors
  • make measurements, store them in influxdb and make graphs with grafana
  • evaluate the measurements

progress:

  • 20190409
    • Prototype built with MH-Z14A and CCS811
    • API Endpoint with node-red configured to store data in influxdb
    • first dashboard in grafana implemented
    • other sensors ordered
  • Progress 20190424
    • MH-Z19b arrived

findings:

  • na

open items:

  • na

log:

20190410:
The CCS811 seems to reset sometimes (no values for several minutes and then starts with 400ppm). I will add a pull up resistor on the I2C bus.

20180424:
CCS811 is quite complex to handle. It has a MCU and you can make firmware updates. The library from adafruit is incomplete, it doesn’t support baseline-functions, which you have to use. I changed to the sparkfun library.

CCS811 didn’t show usable results in mode 3 (measurement every 60s). Now trying mode 1 (every 1s) with a moving average over one minute.

MH-Z19b arrived

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.